A recent statutory rape case in the Circuit Court of Hinds County highlights the unfairness of Mississippi's statutory rape law, and the dangers of online chat.
The Clarion-Ledger reported that a 29 year-old Hinds County man plead guilty to one count of statutory rape of a 14 year-old child. According to the article, the victim entered an online chatroom and solicited the defendant for sex. The victim lied to the defendant and told him that she was 19 years-old. Based on this misrepresentation, the defendant agreed to meet the victim at a motel. They met at the hotel several hours later and had sex.
An investigation revealed that before she solicited the defendant, the victim had gone online and solicited another adult male for sex. She sneaked out of the house to meet the first guy, but they got into an argument and did not have sex with each other.
As a result of his guilty plea, the defendant was sentenced to ten (10) years in prison. Fortunately, all ten (10) years of the sentence was suspended. However, the defendant will be required to register as a sex offender.
How could this man be guilty of statutory rape?
Some would ask exactly how the defendant could be convicted of statutory rape. It's a legitimate question, considering the facts of the case. The undisputed proof was (1) the "victim" solicited the adult for sex, (2) the "victim" lied to the adult about her age, (3) the sex was completely consensual, and (4) the "victim" tried to pull the same stunt with another adult male just hours before she successfully convinced the defendant to meet her for sex.
Considering all of this evidence, it defies logic and good sense that the defendant could be convicted of statutory rape. However, under Mississippi's patently illogical and unfair statutory rape law, the defendant was guilty of this crime. Here's why the defendant was guilty:
Statutory Rape Under Mississippi Law
Under Mississippi Code Section 97-3-65, statutory rape is committed when:
(1) a person 17 years of age or older;
(2) has sexual intercourse with a person who is at least 14, but less than 16, years-old; and
(3) the parties to the act are not married.
In a statutory rape case, this is all the prosecutor has to prove. If each of these elements are proven beyond a reasonable doubt, a person can be convicted of this crime.
In the case cited above, the defendant was 29, and the victim was 14, so the age elements were not in dispute. The defendant also admitted that sexual intercourse took place. Consequently, the State could prove all the elements of statutory rape.
What about the victim lying about her age?
Even though the State could prove all the elements of the crime, it still seems wrong that the defendant could be convicted of statutory rape, considering the victim lied about her age. While this notion might offend one's sense of right-and-wrong, the fact that the victim lied about her age is not a defense to a charge of statutory rape.
Mississippi appellate courts have repeatedly held that the defendant's mistake about the victim's age is not a defense to a charge of statutory rape. Darden v. State, 798 So.2d 632 (Miss.App. 2001). No matter how reasonable the defendant's belief that the victim was above the age of consent, this will not provide a defense to this charge. It is also irrelevant how old or mature the victim looked or acted.
Even where the victim knowingly lies about her age, the defendant is still guilty of statutory rape. Sanders v. State, 825 So.2d 53 (Miss.App. 2002); Daniels v. State, 742 So.2d 1140 (Miss. 1999).
Under the current state of the law, a defendant is not entitled to rely on the victim's representations regarding her age. The fact that the victim lied does not provide a defense. Taken to its logical conclusion, a victim could conceivably go so far as to show the defendant a counterfeit ID showing that she was above the age of consent, and the defendant would still be convicted of statutory rape.
What about the fact that the victim initiated the conversation and solicited sex from the defendant?
Consent of the victim is not a defense to a charge of statutory rape. Phillipson v. State, 943 So.2d 670 (Miss. 2006). No matter how much the victim participated in the act, or how enthusiastic she was for the event to take place, this simply will not provide a defense to statutory rape.
Unfair and Unjust
Under the law, the defendant in this article was guilty. Regardless, this seems to be an unfair and unjust result, in light of the victim's solicitations and lies about her age.
Application of the statutory rape law in this case does not appear to serve the purpose of the law in the first place. Mississippi's statutory rape law is designed to protect children from being exploited for sex, regardless of their consent, because children simply cannot appreciate the significance or consequences of their actions. Phillipson v. State, 943 So.2d 670 (Miss. 2006).
Protection of children who do not understand the consequences of the decision to have sex is a laudable goal. However, that goal was not served by charging the defendant with statutory rape. The "victim" in this case fully understood the significance and consequences of her actions. She solicited the defendant online, lied about her age, made arrangements to meet the defendant at the motel, and had sex with him. She also tried the same thing with another man before she hooked the defendant. In this case, I submit that the "victim" was not a victim at all. She was the actual predator. She knew exactly what she was doing and hardly needed the protection of the law.
This is the problem with the statutory rape statute. There is no defense or "safety valve" to cover circumstances like those presented in this case. As a result, a man was convicted of a sex crime, and forever branded a sex offender. Under these facts, this is a manifest injustice.
Statutory rape cases are tough, but many are still defensible. Defending a statutory rape case in Mississippi requires unique tactics and intensive pretrial investigation and preparation. If you have questions about statutory rape cases or other sex crimes in Mississippi, please contact us. All inquires are held in the strictest confidence, and there is no charge for an initial consultation.